Tutorial

Why Disk Recording?

 

Superior Data Quality (SFDR)

A key reason for the popularity of disk recording for SIGINT applications is its outstanding data quality. For example, Avalon disk recorders offer spurious free dynamic range (SFDR) results that are far beyond anything that would typically be possible using magnetic tape. Figures 1 and 2 (below) offer a direct comparison between the SFDR of a typical 12 MHz S-VHS tape recorder and that of a 12 MHz Avalon AE8222 disk recorder.  They demonstrate that disk recording offers an improvement of at least 20dB over tape recording before even considering other system enhancements such as DSP-based IF/baseband conversion. It would be hard to overstate the importance of this quantum leap in performance for applications requireing to detect low-level signals that would previously have been lost in the tape recorder’s noise floor.

Figure 1:  SFDR measurement from a typical 12 MHz S-VHS tape recorder (<40 dB). Figure 2:  SFDR measurement from a 12 MHz AE8222 baseband disk recorder (>63dB)

Wider Bandwidth

The bandwidth of S-VHS tape recorders (the workhorse of SIGINT recording for many years) has evolved over time from 6 MHz, thru 8 and 12 MHz and finally to 18 MHz. But these increases came at the cost of recording duration and signal quality. In 1998, Avalon introduced its first 50 MHz disk recorder.  This recorded to a group of eight computer hard disks (HDDs) and became an immediate success in a range of critical SIGINT applications.  The maximum practical bandwidth of a disk recorder is no longer media related since it is technically possible to write to as many parallel disks as the bandwidth may require.  So today, the pacing consideration is the availability of suitable COTS analog/digital converters, digital/analog converters and fast DSP processors.  Fortunately, COTS components now support the digitization and down-conversion of Intermediate Frequencies (IFs) of up to 160 MHz and signal bandwidths as high as 80 or 100 MHz.  It will soon be possible to make sustained recordings of a 1 GHz IF at bandwidths of up to 500 MHz bandwidth using the same basic techniques.

Figures 3 and 4 are taken from a typical Avalon 100 MHz baseband recording channel, demonstrating the level of performance that is possible today. 

Figure 3:  SFDR measurement from a typical 100 MHz Avalon baseband channel recording a single 1 MHz tone (>63 dB). Figure 4:  SFDR measurement from a typical 100 MHz Avalon baseband channel recording a pair of tones at 88.5 MHz and 91.5 MHz(>65 dB).